Should You Refinish or Replace Your Bathtub?
Refinishing costs $600-$850. Replacement costs $4,500+. In most cases, refinishing is the smarter choice.
Side-by-Side Comparison
Every factor that matters when making your decision
Replacement
When to Choose Each Option
✓ Choose Refinishing When:
- ✓ Your tub is structurally sound
- ✓ Surface issues: stains, chips, dullness
- ✓ You want to save money
- ✓ You need it done quickly
- ✓ You want to avoid demolition mess
- ✓ You like your current tub size/style
✗ Choose Replacement When:
- ✗ Major structural damage/cracks
- ✗ You want a different size tub
- ✗ Full bathroom remodel planned
- ✗ Converting to walk-in shower
- ✗ Adding accessibility features
- ✗ Budget is not a concern
Replacement Cost Breakdown
Compare to refinishing: $600-$850 all-inclusive
Common Questions
Is refinishing as good as a new tub?+
Yes, a professionally refinished tub looks and feels like new. The finish is smooth, glossy, and durable. Most people can't tell the difference. It lasts 10-15+ years with proper care.
How long does a refinished bathtub last?+
A professionally refinished bathtub lasts 10-15+ years with proper care. We provide a 5-year warranty. Avoid abrasive cleaners and use gentle products to maximize lifespan.
Can all bathtubs be refinished?+
Most bathtubs can be refinished including porcelain, cast iron, fiberglass, and acrylic. The exception is tubs with major structural damage like large cracks or holes. We'll assess your tub and give you an honest recommendation.
Why is replacement so expensive?+
Replacement requires multiple tradespeople (demolition, plumbing, installation, tile work), permits, and materials. The old tub must be demolished and removed, walls repaired, and plumbing often modified. These costs add up quickly.