Bath Fitter Alternative
Comparing acrylic liners vs refinishing? Here's an honest breakdown of process, warranty, and pricing to help you make the right choice.
Looking for a Bath Fitter Alternative?
Bath Fitter is the largest acrylic bathtub liner company in North America. Their process involves installing a custom-molded acrylic shell over your existing tub. It's a quality solution that has worked for millions of homeowners.
However, liners aren't the only option. Bathtub refinishing (reglazing) restores your existing tub surface without adding a liner. Here's how the two approaches compare.
Our approach: We respect all professional bathroom renovation companies. This page compares two different solutions objectively to help you choose what's right for your situation.
Acrylic Liners vs Refinishing
*Pricing based on publicly available information and may vary by location. Always get written quotes. our pricing
What to Consider When Choosing
š Liners vs Refinishing
Acrylic liners install a new surface over your existing tub ā great for covering severe damage but adds thickness. Refinishing restores the original surface with professional coatings ā preserves dimensions and works on unique tub shapes. Choose based on your tub's condition and your budget.
š° Budget Considerations
Refinishing typically costs 50-70% less than acrylic liners. If your tub is structurally sound and you want to maximize value, refinishing is often the smart choice. If you have structural issues or want a full bathroom transformation, liners may be worth the investment. customer reviews
š Tub Shape & Size
Liners work best on standard tub shapes. If you have a clawfoot, corner, garden tub, or vintage fixture, refinishing is usually the only option. Liners also reduce interior dimensions slightly ā something to consider if your tub is already compact.
ā±ļø Long-Term Value
Both solutions can last 10-20 years with proper care. Bath Fitter's lifetime warranty is valuable but consider: at $3,000-$5,000, you could refinish the same tub 4-5 times. Touch-up repairs for refinished tubs are also simple and affordable ($80-$120).
Common Questions About Both Options
Questions people ask when comparing liners and refinishing
Can water get under an acrylic liner?
Quality liner installations seal properly to prevent this. However, if seals fail, moisture can become trapped. With refinishing, there's no gap ā the coating bonds directly to your tub surface, eliminating this concern entirely.
Which lasts longer ā liners or refinishing?
Both last 10-20 years with proper care. Liners may have a slight edge in longevity, but refinishing can be touched up or redone easily and affordably. Consider total cost of ownership, not just initial lifespan.
Is refinishing as durable as an acrylic liner?
Professional refinishing with industrial 2-part epoxy creates an extremely durable surface. It handles daily use, cleaning products, and normal wear. Both options are durable ā they just achieve it differently.
Can I refinish my tub after having a liner installed?
Yes. If you currently have a liner and want it refinished, we can do that. We can also refinish tubs that have been previously refinished. The key is proper surface preparation.
Why Choose Refinishing with Proper Reglazing
Here's what sets us apart as an alternative to liners
Save 50-70%
Professional refinishing at a fraction of liner costs.
Keep Your Tub Size
No reduction in bathtub dimensions or soaking space.
Any Tub Shape
Clawfoot, corner, garden ā we refinish them all.
Get Your Free Quote
See how we compare ā no obligation