Mr. Bathtub Alternative
Comparing bathtub refinishing companies? Here's an honest breakdown of process, warranty, and pricing to help you make the right choice.
Looking for a Mr. Bathtub Alternative?
Mr. Bathtub is a refinishing company that serves various markets. Like all professional refinishers, they offer bathtub restoration services. When comparing refinishing companies, the key factors to evaluate are the same regardless of brand.
If you're exploring alternatives, here's what matters when comparing any refinishing company — including what we offer at Proper Reglazing.
Our approach: We respect all professional refinishers. This page helps you understand what to compare when choosing any refinishing company.
What to Consider When Choosing
🧪 Coating Quality
The coating system matters most for longevity. Ask if they use industrial 2-part epoxy with proper primer. Consumer-grade coatings and shortcuts lead to peeling within 1-2 years. Professional-grade systems last 10-15+ years.
📋 Warranty Terms
A 5-year warranty is industry standard. Ask specifically: What's covered? What voids the warranty? How do you file a claim? Get warranty terms in writing before work begins. customer reviews
💰 Pricing Transparency
Get detailed written quotes. Ask what's included: surface prep, chip repair, drain area. Beware quotes far below market rate ($400 or less for a tub usually means corners will be cut).
⭐ Reviews & Track Record
Check Google reviews, Yelp, and BBB. Look for patterns in feedback. How does the company respond to complaints? Any company can have occasional issues — what matters is how they handle them.
Addressing Common Refinishing Concerns
Questions people ask when researching any refinishing company
What if the finish peels?
Peeling is usually covered under warranty if it's due to workmanship. At Proper Reglazing, we use industrial 2-part epoxy with proper primer — the same process that gives 10-15 year lifespans. If issues arise, our touch-up service is $80-$120.
How do I know if a company uses quality materials?
Ask directly: "Do you use 2-part epoxy?" and "Do you apply primer first?" Professional refinishers will explain their process clearly. If they're vague about materials or process, that's a red flag.
Should I choose the cheapest option?
Usually not. Prices significantly below market rate ($400 or less for a tub) often mean inferior coatings, rushed prep work, or lack of proper ventilation. You'll end up paying twice when it fails. Mid-range pricing ($600-$850) is typical for quality work.
How do I verify a company is legitimate?
Check for: proper business licensing, liability insurance, physical address or established online presence, consistent reviews across platforms, and willingness to provide references. Legitimate companies provide contracts and accept credit cards.
Why Customers Choose Proper Reglazing
Here's what sets us apart
5-Year Warranty
Full coverage with documented touch-up service at transparent pricing.
Industrial Coatings
2-part epoxy with proper primer. Same process used by hotel chains.
Direct Communication
Talk directly to the technician who'll do your work. No call centers.
Get Your Free Quote
See how we compare — no obligation