Bathtub Refinishing Scams to Avoid
Red flags, warning signs, and how to protect yourself from low-quality refinishing work.
Why This Matters
Most bathtub refinishing companies are legitimate professionals. However, some cut corners or use inferior materials to offer low prices — leaving homeowners with peeling finishes and wasted money.
The worst part? A failed refinishing job costs you twice: first for the bad work, then to strip it and do it right. Here's how to avoid that scenario.
Key insight: Most "failed" refinishing jobs fail because of poor materials or rushed prep work — not because refinishing doesn't work. Professional-grade refinishing lasts 10-15+ years.
Red Flags to Watch For
Warning signs that suggest low-quality work or potential scams
Unusually Low Prices
The red flag: Quotes of $300-$400 or less for a bathtub refinishing.
Why it's a problem: Quality materials alone cost $100-$150. Prices this low mean they're using inferior coatings, skipping proper prep, or rushing the job. The finish will likely peel within 1-2 years — then you pay again to fix it.
Cash-Only Payment
The red flag: They only accept cash or won't provide receipts.
Why it's a problem: Legitimate businesses accept credit cards and provide proper documentation. Cash-only often means they're avoiding taxes or don't want a paper trail if you have complaints.
No Written Quote or Contract
The red flag: They give a verbal price but won't put it in writing.
Why it's a problem: Without written documentation, you have no recourse if the price changes or if there's a dispute. Always get detailed written quotes specifying exactly what's included.
No Warranty or Vague Terms
The red flag: No warranty offered, or verbal-only "guarantees."
Why it's a problem: Quality refinishers offer 5-year warranties in writing because they stand behind their work. No warranty suggests they know the finish won't last — or they plan to disappear if there are problems.
Vague About Materials
The red flag: They can't or won't explain what coating system they use.
Why it's a problem: Professional refinishers use industrial 2-part epoxy with proper primer and will happily explain their process. Vague answers often mean they're using consumer-grade products from hardware stores.
Rushing or Pressure Tactics
The red flag: "This price is only good today" or refusing to let you think about it.
Why it's a problem: Legitimate businesses don't need to pressure you. High-pressure tactics often hide something — whether it's inflated prices or quality problems they don't want you to discover by comparison shopping.
No Verifiable Identity
The red flag: Only a cell phone number, no business address, no website.
Why it's a problem: If something goes wrong, you need to be able to find them. Legitimate businesses have verifiable identities — websites, Google listings, physical addresses. Anonymous operators can disappear when problems arise.
No Contractor License
The red flag: They can't provide a contractor license number or aren't registered with the state.
Why it's a problem: In California and most states, bathtub refinishing requires a valid contractor license. Unlicensed contractors have no accountability — you can't file complaints with the licensing board, and your warranty is worthless if they disappear. Always verify the license number with your state's contractor licensing board before hiring.
Signs of a Quality Refinisher
Uses industrial 2-part epoxy with primer
Can explain their process clearly and specifically our pricing
Offers 5-year warranty in writing
Clear terms specifying what's covered and how to file claims
Transparent pricing ($600-$850 for tubs)
Written quotes detailing exactly what's included customer reviews
Strong reviews on multiple platforms
Consistent positive feedback on Google, Yelp, BBB
Accepts credit cards, provides receipts
Normal business practices that protect you
Valid contractor license
Licensed with the state — verify the number before hiring
Verifiable identity and business presence
Website, address, insurance — you can find them if needed
Common Questions
What to do if you encounter problems
What if I already hired someone and the finish is peeling?
Contact the company immediately and document everything with photos. If they have a warranty, file a claim. If they won't respond, leave honest reviews to warn others. For your fix, you'll need a quality refinisher to strip the failed coating and redo it properly — this costs more than the original job due to the stripping required.
Can I use small claims court for a bad refinishing job?
Yes, if you have documentation (written quote, photos, proof of payment). Small claims court limits vary by state (usually $2,500-$10,000). The challenge is finding the contractor if they've disappeared — which is why verifiable business identity matters upfront.
Why does cheap refinishing fail so quickly?
Usually one of three reasons: (1) Consumer-grade coatings instead of industrial 2-part epoxy, (2) Skipping proper surface preparation (cleaning, etching, priming), or (3) Rushing the process. All three save time/money for the contractor but result in finishes that peel within 1-2 years.
How do I report a scam contractor?
File complaints with your state's contractor licensing board, the BBB, and your local consumer protection office. Leave detailed reviews on Google and Yelp. If you paid by credit card, you may be able to dispute the charge for services not rendered as promised.
Why Customers Trust Proper Reglazing
We do everything the right way
Licensed Contractor
Fully licensed with the state. Verify our credentials.
5-Year Warranty
Written warranty. Clear terms. We honor it.
Industrial Coatings
2-part epoxy with proper prep. 10-15+ year lifespan.
Transparent Business
Written quotes, receipts, credit cards accepted.
Get Your Free Quote
Honest pricing, quality work